UPR Sexual Rights Database

Search & Filters

Select one or more parameters to begin your search. You may also search by keyword at any time.

UN Member State that is reviewed on its human rights record as part of the UPR process.

Categories of the types of information used during reviews

Show advanced filters
Source of Reference

Recommending State

UN Member State or Permanent Observer making sexual rights related recommendations, comments or asking questions to the State under Review.

Review Documentation

Sources of information used as the basis for a State’s review.  Includes the State’s National Report, UN Compilation Report and a Stakeholder Summary.

UN Regional Group to which State under Review belongs.

UN Regional Group to which Recommending State belongs.

This will only match recommendations where the Source of Review is a State.

Implementation notes

State responses to recommendations and issues raised in the UN Compilation and Stakeholder summary.

Displaying 46126 - 46150 of 58130 recommendations found
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Australia

    Australia
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    PIF
    Commonwealth
    Issue:
    • Gender equality
    • Empowerment of women
    • Women's participation
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Continue already commendable efforts to achieve gender equality and women's empowerment, including through greater participation by women in political life at the local and national level.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Philippines

    Philippines
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    ASEAN
    Issue:
    • Sexual abuse
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Strengthen measures to address domestic violence and sexual abuse including ensuring effective access to support services, remedies, and means of protection to women victims.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Marginalized groups of women
    • Discrimination based on sexual orientation
    • Women's and / or girls' rights
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    CRPD recommended that Slovenia explicitly incorporate into its anti-discrimination legislation, policies and strategies the recognition of multiple and intersectional discrimination based on sex, age, ethnic background or sexual orientation or on migrant, asylum-seeking, refugee, disability or any other status. [Para 8]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • Sexual violence
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    AI stated that the legal definition of rape in the Criminal Code was based on force, threat of force or coercion, rather than the lack of consent, and was, therefore, not in line with international human rights law and standard. It recommended that Slovenia revise the definition of rape in the Criminal Code so that it is based on the absence of consent. [Para 21]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Iran

    Iran
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    OIC
    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To address the issue of gender-based violence in a comprehensive manner.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 29) Since 2010, Slovenia signed and ratified the following international treaties:
    CoE Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence; signed on 8 September 2011.

    Para 73) In 2009, Slovenia adopted the Resolution on the 2009-2014 National Programme on Prevention of Family Violence (NPPFV). This strategic document sets out objectives, measures and key players to reduce and prevent domestic violence. The document aims to combine measures implemented by various ministries and provides for effective activities to reduce domestic violence, both in terms of identification and prevention. Therefore, the Resolution also provides for the implementation of a national awareness-raising campaign on the issue of violence and for reducing the extent of such deviant behaviour in every society. Rules were adopted in certain fields to implement the 2008 Family Violence Prevention Act (FVPA), effectively provide assistance to children and cooperate with other authorities.

    Para 74) The two-year nation-wide awareness raising campaign "VESNA - to live a life free of violence" officially started on 7 March 2014 with a national conference. The target group is women of three generations (young women, adults and old women), for whom different, target-oriented activities have been envisaged. Activities are tailored to the needs and lifestyle of each target group.

    Para 75) Several other sector-specific implementing acts on education, health care, social security, and the police have been passed to implement the FVPA, effectively provide assistance to children and cooperate with other authorities.

    Para 76) The Slovenian Research Agency, the OEO and the MoI/Police co-financed the target research project "Violence and Responses to it in the Private Sphere and Partnerships". At the end of 2010, the results of the first empirical national research on violence in the private sphere and partnerships were published, and followed at the end of 2011 by analyses on the work of the Police, courts and social services concerning violence against women and domestic violence. The research has shown that the number of cases of domestic violence that are detected, identified and processed by institutions is increasing. This is also due to the implementation of legislation that both enables and imposes the obligation of institutions to provide effective assistance to victims and to prosecute offenders. In addition, the number of cases processed also increased as a result of the victims' increased willingness to seek help and the increased awareness and sensitivity of staff in institutions established to help such victims.

    Para 77) Adopted in 2013, the Police Tasks and Powers Act significantly upgraded the police restraining order. Police officers may impose such a measure on the offender not only on the scene of the offence, but also immediately after the offender has been apprehended, regardless of location. An offender who has repeatedly violated a restraining order may be detained by the Police and, at the same time, a fine may be imposed. For the cases when the place that the offender must not approach is an education institution attended by a victim who is a child or a minor, the legal basis was added to inform the relevant personnel at the education institutions of the duration of the restraining order or other information vital to the protection of the victim.

    Para 78) With a view to raising public awareness, the Police publish on its web page, in several foreign languages, information on domestic violence and on police procedures.

    Para 79) Housing capacities for women victims of violence have increased. One of the safe houses has also been adapted for the needs of disabled persons. One crisis centre has been adapted for the needs of older people. The network of crisis centres and shelters expanded to regions in which such services were previously unavailable, and the housing capacities for victims of violence are currently provided for.

    Para 80) NGOs caution about the changed criminal offence of threat under Article 135 of the Criminal Code, which stipulates that the threatening of the security of another person without any consequences and when only one person is involved is liable to private prosecution. This change was made particularly due to prosecutors' experience of a large number of withdrawn complaints of injured parties during the later stages of the procedure. The adequacy of this solution is being reviewed in 2014.

    Para 81) The available statistics show the improved effectiveness of justice in terms of prosecutions and conviction related to the offence of domestic violence under Article 191 of the Criminal Code.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Israel

    Israel
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Issue:
    • International human rights instruments
    • Women's and / or girls' rights
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Unclear Response
    Contents:
    Repeal provisions of the Marriage and Family Relations Act that are not compliant with the CRC.
    Explanation
    Noted. The Government of the Republic of Slovenia is currently not planning to change this act.
    Implementation
    UN Compilation:
    Para 13) The HR Committee regretted that the amendments to the Law on Marriage and Family Relations granting, on an equal basis, the rights of same-sex couples to inherit, to access reproductive treatments and to adopt children were made subject to a referendum in December 2015 notwithstanding the provisions of the Constitution to the contrary, and that they were rejected.

  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Algeria

    Algeria
    Regional group
    Africa Group
    Political group
    AU
    OIC
    AL
    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Strengthen the measures undertaken to combat domestic violence in general and violence against children in particular.
    Explanation
    We consider that the activities for the implementation of this recommendation are already ongoing. The government is currently preparing a new resolution on equal opportunities of women and men that includes specific measures to address violence against women
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 66) Efforts for preventing violence against women continue. A resolution on a national plan for the prevention of family violence and violence against women is in preparation. The resolution will include guidelines for working with sexually abused children. In 2019, Slovenia is preparing the first report on the implementation of the Council of Europe Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence.

    UN Compilation:
    Para 18) The HR Committee and the CESCR were concerned about the high prevalence of domestic violence in Slovenia and the limited effectiveness of mechanisms to protect victims of domestic violence, including the non-enforcement of restraining orders issued against alleged perpetrators.
    Para 36) [CEDAW] noted with concern the failure to comprehensively prohibit all forms of violence against women in both the public and private spheres and the lenient sentences imposed by courts on perpetrators of acts of domestic violence. It also noted with concern that the network of shelters and crisis centres did not cover the entire territory of Slovenia and that free counselling and assistance were not accessible to all women who were victims of violence.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    • International human rights instruments
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    ... CRC also recommended the full harmonization of Slovenian national legislation with OP-CRC-SC, particularly by explicitly prohibiting the sale of children and forced adoptions. [Para 29]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Ukraine

    Ukraine
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    CIS
    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To continue its efforts to effectively protect children's rights and to combat child trafficking, child prostitution and pornography.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    National Report

    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    • Trafficking in women and / or girls
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    N/A
    Contents:
    In 2008, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs financed, for the fifth consecutive year, the project titled “Implementing the mechanism for reconnaissance, assistance and protection of the victims of trafficking and/or sexual abuse in asylum proceedings in Slovenia” (PATS). There is a regional component to the project, which is implemented also in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina. [Para 43]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Neglected
    Contents:
    "Fundación Mundial Déjame Vivir en Paz (FMDVEP) considered necessary that Slovenia recognize the rights of homosexuals to adopt a child. [Para 9]"
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Women's and / or girls' rights
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Neglected
    Contents:
    Address the low enrolment of female children with disabilities in school. [Para 32; CRC]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Albania

    Albania
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    OIC
    OIF
    Issue:
    • Gender equality
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Continue the revision of the law on equal opportunities for men and women.
    Explanation
    Slovenia will continue to promote gender equality, including by upgrading the legislation in this field. In 2019, Slovenia introduced amendments to the Equal Opportunities for Women and Men Act with the aim to increase the share of the under-represented sex in the composition of the bodies of the Government and local authorities as well as in the management of bodies governed by public law.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Lebanon

    Lebanon
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    OIC
    AL
    OIF
    Issue:
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Continue efforts to combat domestic violence and strengthen protection mechanisms for the victims.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Iceland

    Iceland
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Issue:
    • Intersex persons' rights
    • Discrimination based on sexual orientation
    • Discrimination based on gender identity
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Strengthen activities and laws aimed at the elimination of discrimination in society, other intolerance and hate speech against minorities and other groups, including based on sexual orientation, gender identity or sex characteristics.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Marginalized groups of women
    • Trafficking in women and / or girls
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    CEDAW ... recommended that Slovenia strengthen measures to identify and provide support to women at risk of trafficking, in particular Roma, migrant, refugee and asylum-seeking women, and measures aimed at addressing the root causes of trafficking. [Para 23]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Stakeholder Summary

    Issue:
    • HIV and AIDS
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    34th Session, November 2019
    Status:
    Not Followed up with a Recommendation
    Contents:
    JS1 recommended that Slovenia continue combating stigma, exclusion and discrimination against persons with HIV/AIDS. [Para 18]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Spain

    Spain
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    EU
    OEI
    Issue:
    • Domestic violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Unclear Response
    Contents:
    To promulgate a law on domestic violence that includes penalties and options for the treatment of those responsible for such crimes, and to undertake an awareness-raising campaign regarding domestic violence
    Explanation
    Slovenia accepts the recommendation regarding the treatment of those responsible for domestic violence. Options for treatment are provided in
    partnership with NGOs.

    Slovenia also accepts recommendation on awareness-raising campaigns.

    Slovenia cannot accept the recommendation to promulgate a law on domestic violence due to the national system of criminal legislation. In Slovenia, criminal offences and sanctions are defined in the Criminal Code and in the Minor Offences Act.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 29) Since 2010, Slovenia signed and ratified the following international treaties:
    CoE Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence; signed on 8 September 2011.

    Para 73) In 2009, Slovenia adopted the Resolution on the 2009-2014 National Programme on Prevention of Family Violence (NPPFV). This strategic document sets out objectives, measures and key players to reduce and prevent domestic violence. The document aims to combine measures implemented by various ministries and provides for effective activities to reduce domestic violence, both in terms of identification and prevention. Therefore, the Resolution also provides for the implementation of a national awareness-raising campaign on the issue of violence and for reducing the extent of such deviant behaviour in every society. Rules were adopted in certain fields to implement the 2008 Family Violence Prevention Act (FVPA), effectively provide assistance to children and cooperate with other authorities.

    Para 74) The two-year nation-wide awareness raising campaign "VESNA - to live a life free of violence" officially started on 7 March 2014 with a national conference. The target group is women of three generations (young women, adults and old women), for whom different, target-oriented activities have been envisaged. Activities are tailored to the needs and lifestyle of each target group.

    Para 75) Several other sector-specific implementing acts on education, health care, social security, and the police have been passed to implement the FVPA, effectively provide assistance to children and cooperate with other authorities.

    Para 76) The Slovenian Research Agency, the OEO and the MoI/Police co-financed the target research project "Violence and Responses to it in the Private Sphere and Partnerships". At the end of 2010, the results of the first empirical national research on violence in the private sphere and partnerships were published, and followed at the end of 2011 by analyses on the work of the Police, courts and social services concerning violence against women and domestic violence. The research has shown that the number of cases of domestic violence that are detected, identified and processed by institutions is increasing. This is also due to the implementation of legislation that both enables and imposes the obligation of institutions to provide effective assistance to victims and to prosecute offenders. In addition, the number of cases processed also increased as a result of the victims' increased willingness to seek help and the increased awareness and sensitivity of staff in institutions established to help such victims.

    Para 77) Adopted in 2013, the Police Tasks and Powers Act significantly upgraded the police restraining order. Police officers may impose such a measure on the offender not only on the scene of the offence, but also immediately after the offender has been apprehended, regardless of location. An offender who has repeatedly violated a restraining order may be detained by the Police and, at the same time, a fine may be imposed. For the cases when the place that the offender must not approach is an education institution attended by a victim who is a child or a minor, the legal basis was added to inform the relevant personnel at the education institutions of the duration of the restraining order or other information vital to the protection of the victim.

    Para 78) With a view to raising public awareness, the Police publish on its web page, in several foreign languages, information on domestic violence and on police procedures.

    Para 80) NGOs caution about the changed criminal offence of threat under Article 135 of the Criminal Code, which stipulates that the threatening of the security of another person without any consequences and when only one person is involved is liable to private prosecution. This change was made particularly due to prosecutors' experience of a large number of withdrawn complaints of injured parties during the later stages of the procedure. The adequacy of this solution is being reviewed in 2014.

    Para 81) The available statistics show the improved effectiveness of justice in terms of prosecutions and conviction related to the offence of domestic violence under Article 191 of the Criminal Code.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Slovakia

    Slovakia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Issue:
    • International human rights instruments
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Ratify the OP-CRC-IC.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 5. After the second cycle, Slovenia ratified … the OP-CRC-IC (20 March 2018).
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Iran

    Iran
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    OIC
    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    Take the necessary measures for setting up a comprehensive national strategy to prevent and address all forms of violence against women and children.
    Explanation
    We consider that the activities for the implementation of this recommendation are already ongoing. The government is currently preparing a new resolution on equal opportunities of women and men that includes specific measures to address violence against women.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 66) Efforts for preventing violence against women continue. A resolution on a national plan for the prevention of family violence and violence against women is in preparation. The resolution will include guidelines for working with sexually abused children. In 2019, Slovenia is preparing the first report on the implementation of the Council of Europe Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence.

    UN Compilation:
    Para 18) The HR Committee and the CESCR were concerned about the high prevalence of domestic violence in Slovenia and the limited effectiveness of mechanisms to protect victims of domestic violence, including the non-enforcement of restraining orders issued against alleged perpetrators.
    Para 36) [CEDAW] noted with concern the failure to comprehensively prohibit all forms of violence against women in both the public and private spheres and the lenient sentences imposed by courts on perpetrators of acts of domestic violence. It also noted with concern that the network of shelters and crisis centres did not cover the entire territory of Slovenia and that free counselling and assistance were not accessible to all women who were victims of violence.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Violence against women / gender-based violence
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    20th session, November 2014
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    CAT remained concerned about violence against women and girls and recommended, inter alia, that Slovenia prevent and prosecute all forms of violence against women and children, including domestic violence, and implement the National Programme of Family Violence Prevention (2009-2014). [Para 24]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Canada

    Canada
    Regional group
    WEOG
    Political group
    OAS
    OIF
    Commonwealth
    Issue:
    • Discrimination based on sexual orientation
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To eliminate all other forms of disparity in the treatment of heterosexual and same-sex couples, in order to ensure full equality and non-discrimination.
    Implementation
    National Report:
    Para 52) On 16 June 2011, the NA adopted the Family Code, according to which a same-sex union (partnership, extramarital union) is equal to a union between a man and a woman. The Act was rejected in a referendum held on 25 March 2012, with 45.45% voting for its adoption and 54.55% against. The relevant ministry has prepared working documents for a new family code and a draft law on civil partnership. In April 2014, the draft law was submitted for inter-ministerial consideration and public debate. The procedure has been suspended following the resignation of the Government. At the 2nd IDAHO Forum in May 2014, Slovenia was among 17 countries that signed the Declaration of Intent, which draws attention to the issues of homophobia and transphobia.
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    Iran

    Iran
    Regional group
    Asia-Pacific Group
    Political group
    OIC
    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    Type:
    Recommendation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Accepted
    Contents:
    To develop a national plan of action aimed at addressing the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography, and to provide adequate human and financial resources for its implementation
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    National Report

    Issue:
    • Rights of same-sex desiring persons
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    N/A
    Contents:
    Decision U-I-425/06-10 of July 2009 of the Constitutional Court established the inconsistency of Article 22 of the Registration of a Same-Sex Civil Partnership Act regulating inheritance with Article 14, paragraph 1, of the Constitution. The Court establishes that the position of partners in registered same-sex partnerships is in its essential factual and legal aspects comparable with the position of spouses as regards the right to inheritance from a deceased partner. The differences in the regulation of inheritance between spouses and between partners in registered same-sex partnerships are therefore not based on any objective, non-personal circumstance, but on sexual orientation. Until the established inconsistency is remedied, the same rules apply for inheritance between partners in registered same-sex partnerships as apply for inheritance between spouses in accordance with the Inheritance Act. The National Assembly is obliged to remedy the established inconsistency within six months from the publication of this decision. [Para 20]
  • State Under Review:

    Slovenia

    Slovenia
    Regional group
    EEG
    Political group
    EU
    Source Of Reference:

    UN Compilation

    Issue:
    • Sexual exploitation / slavery
    Type:
    Review Documentation
    Session:
    7th session, February 2010
    Status:
    Reference Addressed
    Contents:
    In 2009, CRC was concerned at the weak enforcement of legislation relating to offences referred to in OP-CRC-SC, in particular, the prosecution and punishment of those responsible for acts involving the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography. It recommended that Slovenia take the appropriate measures to expand training activities for the judiciary, prosecutors, police and other public officials so as to ensure the prosecution and punishment of perpetrators of acts prohibited by OP-CRC-SC. [Para 22]